Gaea's Liege

"Simon Cooper" <swcooper.DeleteThis@conecast.net> writes:
> When Gaea's Liege attacks in a two headed giant game, what's its
> power/toughness?
>
> I suspect I incorrectly ruled for just one player's forests, whereas seems
> to me the sum of the two is more likely the current philosophy. Just
> doesn't seem consistent with the way you assign damage to only one player
> (and of course, someone else was trying to split his damage from an Ophidian
> eye'd creature to both players...)

What there an official answer ever posted to this? (I've been not
reading this newsgroup for a while, and I'm finally catching up. But
even Google Groups doesn't seem to show any answer other than Jeff
Heikkinen's.)

At the prerelease, I ruled that it was the sum of the two
players. The relevant text on Gaea's Liege is "As long as Gaea's Liege
is attacking, its power and toughness are each equal to the number of
Forests defending player controls." I figured that this was similar to
landwalk's text of "A creature with landwalk is unblockable as long as
the defending player controls at least one land with the specified
subtype and/or supertype" being interpreted as "...as long as *a*
defending players controls...", so I treating the Liege as "...number
of Forests *a* defending player controls," meaning that for each Forest,
if it's controlled by a defending player, it counts.

Selecting an opponent seems really strange to me, as it's a static
ability applying all the time. When would you select the opponent?

The only other answer would be for the Liege to have more than one
power/toughness (like the pre-errata Duplicant with more than one
imprinted card). But I didn't want to go there, so I ruled that it was
the sum.

But an official answer to this would be kind of nice.

--
Peter C.
 >> Stay informed about: Gaea's Liege 

"Simon Cooper" <swcooper.DeleteThis@conecast.net> writes:
> When Gaea's Liege attacks in a two headed giant game, what's its
> power/toughness?
>
> I suspect I incorrectly ruled for just one player's forests, whereas seems
> to me the sum of the two is more likely the current philosophy. Just
> doesn't seem consistent with the way you assign damage to only one player
> (and of course, someone else was trying to split his damage from an Ophidian
> eye'd creature to both players...)

What there an official answer ever posted to this? (I've been not
reading this newsgroup for a while, and I'm finally catching up. But
even Google Groups doesn't seem to show any answer other than Jeff
Heikkinen's.)

At the prerelease, I ruled that it was the sum of the two
players. The relevant text on Gaea's Liege is "As long as Gaea's Liege
is attacking, its power and toughness are each equal to the number of
Forests defending player controls." I figured that this was similar to
landwalk's text of "A creature with landwalk is unblockable as long as
the defending player controls at least one land with the specified
subtype and/or supertype" being interpreted as "...as long as *a*
defending players controls...", so I treating the Liege as "...number
of Forests *a* defending player controls," meaning that for each Forest,
if it's controlled by a defending player, it counts.

Selecting an opponent seems really strange to me, as it's a static
ability applying all the time. When would you select the opponent?

The only other answer would be for the Liege to have more than one
power/toughness (like the pre-errata Duplicant with more than one
imprinted card). But I didn't want to go there, so I ruled that it was
the sum.

But an official answer to this would be kind of nice.

--
Peter C.
 >> Stay informed about: Gaea's Liege 

"Simon Cooper" <swcooper.DeleteThis@conecast.net> writes:
> When Gaea's Liege attacks in a two headed giant game, what's its
> power/toughness?
>
> I suspect I incorrectly ruled for just one player's forests, whereas seems
> to me the sum of the two is more likely the current philosophy. Just
> doesn't seem consistent with the way you assign damage to only one player
> (and of course, someone else was trying to split his damage from an Ophidian
> eye'd creature to both players...)

What there an official answer ever posted to this? (I've been not
reading this newsgroup for a while, and I'm finally catching up. But
even Google Groups doesn't seem to show any answer other than Jeff
Heikkinen's.)

At the prerelease, I ruled that it was the sum of the two
players. The relevant text on Gaea's Liege is "As long as Gaea's Liege
is attacking, its power and toughness are each equal to the number of
Forests defending player controls." I figured that this was similar to
landwalk's text of "A creature with landwalk is unblockable as long as
the defending player controls at least one land with the specified
subtype and/or supertype" being interpreted as "...as long as *a*
defending players controls...", so I treating the Liege as "...number
of Forests *a* defending player controls," meaning that for each Forest,
if it's controlled by a defending player, it counts.

Selecting an opponent seems really strange to me, as it's a static
ability applying all the time. When would you select the opponent?

The only other answer would be for the Liege to have more than one
power/toughness (like the pre-errata Duplicant with more than one
imprinted card). But I didn't want to go there, so I ruled that it was
the sum.

But an official answer to this would be kind of nice.

--
Peter C.
 >> Stay informed about: Gaea's Liege 

"Simon Cooper" <swcooper.RemoveThis@conecast.net> writes:
> When Gaea's Liege attacks in a two headed giant game, what's its
> power/toughness?
>
> I suspect I incorrectly ruled for just one player's forests, whereas seems
> to me the sum of the two is more likely the current philosophy. Just
> doesn't seem consistent with the way you assign damage to only one player
> (and of course, someone else was trying to split his damage from an Ophidian
> eye'd creature to both players...)

What there an official answer ever posted to this? (I've been not
reading this newsgroup for a while, and I'm finally catching up. But
even Google Groups doesn't seem to show any answer other than Jeff
Heikkinen's.)

At the prerelease, I ruled that it was the sum of the two
players. The relevant text on Gaea's Liege is "As long as Gaea's Liege
is attacking, its power and toughness are each equal to the number of
Forests defending player controls." I figured that this was similar to
landwalk's text of "A creature with landwalk is unblockable as long as
the defending player controls at least one land with the specified
subtype and/or supertype" being interpreted as "...as long as *a*
defending players controls...", so I treating the Liege as "...number
of Forests *a* defending player controls," meaning that for each Forest,
if it's controlled by a defending player, it counts.

Selecting an opponent seems really strange to me, as it's a static
ability applying all the time. When would you select the opponent?

The only other answer would be for the Liege to have more than one
power/toughness (like the pre-errata Duplicant with more than one
imprinted card). But I didn't want to go there, so I ruled that it was
the sum.

But an official answer to this would be kind of nice.

--
Peter C.
 >> Stay informed about: Gaea's Liege 

"Simon Cooper" <swcooper DeleteThis @conecast.net> writes:
> When Gaea's Liege attacks in a two headed giant game, what's its
> power/toughness?
>
> I suspect I incorrectly ruled for just one player's forests, whereas seems
> to me the sum of the two is more likely the current philosophy. Just
> doesn't seem consistent with the way you assign damage to only one player
> (and of course, someone else was trying to split his damage from an Ophidian
> eye'd creature to both players...)

What there an official answer ever posted to this? (I've been not
reading this newsgroup for a while, and I'm finally catching up. But
even Google Groups doesn't seem to show any answer other than Jeff
Heikkinen's.)

At the prerelease, I ruled that it was the sum of the two
players. The relevant text on Gaea's Liege is "As long as Gaea's Liege
is attacking, its power and toughness are each equal to the number of
Forests defending player controls." I figured that this was similar to
landwalk's text of "A creature with landwalk is unblockable as long as
the defending player controls at least one land with the specified
subtype and/or supertype" being interpreted as "...as long as *a*
defending players controls...", so I treating the Liege as "...number
of Forests *a* defending player controls," meaning that for each Forest,
if it's controlled by a defending player, it counts.

Selecting an opponent seems really strange to me, as it's a static
ability applying all the time. When would you select the opponent?

The only other answer would be for the Liege to have more than one
power/toughness (like the pre-errata Duplicant with more than one
imprinted card). But I didn't want to go there, so I ruled that it was
the sum.

But an official answer to this would be kind of nice.

--
Peter C.
 >> Stay informed about: Gaea's Liege 

"Simon Cooper" <swcooper DeleteThis @conecast.net> writes:
> When Gaea's Liege attacks in a two headed giant game, what's its
> power/toughness?
>
> I suspect I incorrectly ruled for just one player's forests, whereas seems
> to me the sum of the two is more likely the current philosophy. Just
> doesn't seem consistent with the way you assign damage to only one player
> (and of course, someone else was trying to split his damage from an Ophidian
> eye'd creature to both players...)

What there an official answer ever posted to this? (I've been not
reading this newsgroup for a while, and I'm finally catching up. But
even Google Groups doesn't seem to show any answer other than Jeff
Heikkinen's.)

At the prerelease, I ruled that it was the sum of the two
players. The relevant text on Gaea's Liege is "As long as Gaea's Liege
is attacking, its power and toughness are each equal to the number of
Forests defending player controls." I figured that this was similar to
landwalk's text of "A creature with landwalk is unblockable as long as
the defending player controls at least one land with the specified
subtype and/or supertype" being interpreted as "...as long as *a*
defending players controls...", so I treating the Liege as "...number
of Forests *a* defending player controls," meaning that for each Forest,
if it's controlled by a defending player, it counts.

Selecting an opponent seems really strange to me, as it's a static
ability applying all the time. When would you select the opponent?

The only other answer would be for the Liege to have more than one
power/toughness (like the pre-errata Duplicant with more than one
imprinted card). But I didn't want to go there, so I ruled that it was
the sum.

But an official answer to this would be kind of nice.

--
Peter C.
 >> Stay informed about: Gaea's Liege 

"Simon Cooper" <swcooper.RemoveThis@conecast.net> writes:
> When Gaea's Liege attacks in a two headed giant game, what's its
> power/toughness?
>
> I suspect I incorrectly ruled for just one player's forests, whereas seems
> to me the sum of the two is more likely the current philosophy. Just
> doesn't seem consistent with the way you assign damage to only one player
> (and of course, someone else was trying to split his damage from an Ophidian
> eye'd creature to both players...)

What there an official answer ever posted to this? (I've been not
reading this newsgroup for a while, and I'm finally catching up. But
even Google Groups doesn't seem to show any answer other than Jeff
Heikkinen's.)

At the prerelease, I ruled that it was the sum of the two
players. The relevant text on Gaea's Liege is "As long as Gaea's Liege
is attacking, its power and toughness are each equal to the number of
Forests defending player controls." I figured that this was similar to
landwalk's text of "A creature with landwalk is unblockable as long as
the defending player controls at least one land with the specified
subtype and/or supertype" being interpreted as "...as long as *a*
defending players controls...", so I treating the Liege as "...number
of Forests *a* defending player controls," meaning that for each Forest,
if it's controlled by a defending player, it counts.

Selecting an opponent seems really strange to me, as it's a static
ability applying all the time. When would you select the opponent?

The only other answer would be for the Liege to have more than one
power/toughness (like the pre-errata Duplicant with more than one
imprinted card). But I didn't want to go there, so I ruled that it was
the sum.

But an official answer to this would be kind of nice.

--
Peter C.
 >> Stay informed about: Gaea's Liege 

"Simon Cooper" <swcooper.DeleteThis@conecast.net> writes:
> When Gaea's Liege attacks in a two headed giant game, what's its
> power/toughness?
>
> I suspect I incorrectly ruled for just one player's forests, whereas seems
> to me the sum of the two is more likely the current philosophy. Just
> doesn't seem consistent with the way you assign damage to only one player
> (and of course, someone else was trying to split his damage from an Ophidian
> eye'd creature to both players...)

What there an official answer ever posted to this? (I've been not
reading this newsgroup for a while, and I'm finally catching up. But
even Google Groups doesn't seem to show any answer other than Jeff
Heikkinen's.)

At the prerelease, I ruled that it was the sum of the two
players. The relevant text on Gaea's Liege is "As long as Gaea's Liege
is attacking, its power and toughness are each equal to the number of
Forests defending player controls." I figured that this was similar to
landwalk's text of "A creature with landwalk is unblockable as long as
the defending player controls at least one land with the specified
subtype and/or supertype" being interpreted as "...as long as *a*
defending players controls...", so I treating the Liege as "...number
of Forests *a* defending player controls," meaning that for each Forest,
if it's controlled by a defending player, it counts.

Selecting an opponent seems really strange to me, as it's a static
ability applying all the time. When would you select the opponent?

The only other answer would be for the Liege to have more than one
power/toughness (like the pre-errata Duplicant with more than one
imprinted card). But I didn't want to go there, so I ruled that it was
the sum.

But an official answer to this would be kind of nice.

--
Peter C.
 >> Stay informed about: Gaea's Liege 

"Simon Cooper" <swcooper.DeleteThis@conecast.net> writes:
> When Gaea's Liege attacks in a two headed giant game, what's its
> power/toughness?
>
> I suspect I incorrectly ruled for just one player's forests, whereas seems
> to me the sum of the two is more likely the current philosophy. Just
> doesn't seem consistent with the way you assign damage to only one player
> (and of course, someone else was trying to split his damage from an Ophidian
> eye'd creature to both players...)

What there an official answer ever posted to this? (I've been not
reading this newsgroup for a while, and I'm finally catching up. But
even Google Groups doesn't seem to show any answer other than Jeff
Heikkinen's.)

At the prerelease, I ruled that it was the sum of the two
players. The relevant text on Gaea's Liege is "As long as Gaea's Liege
is attacking, its power and toughness are each equal to the number of
Forests defending player controls." I figured that this was similar to
landwalk's text of "A creature with landwalk is unblockable as long as
the defending player controls at least one land with the specified
subtype and/or supertype" being interpreted as "...as long as *a*
defending players controls...", so I treating the Liege as "...number
of Forests *a* defending player controls," meaning that for each Forest,
if it's controlled by a defending player, it counts.

Selecting an opponent seems really strange to me, as it's a static
ability applying all the time. When would you select the opponent?

The only other answer would be for the Liege to have more than one
power/toughness (like the pre-errata Duplicant with more than one
imprinted card). But I didn't want to go there, so I ruled that it was
the sum.

But an official answer to this would be kind of nice.

--
Peter C.
 >> Stay informed about: Gaea's Liege 

"Simon Cooper" <swcooper.RemoveThis@conecast.net> writes:
> When Gaea's Liege attacks in a two headed giant game, what's its
> power/toughness?
>
> I suspect I incorrectly ruled for just one player's forests, whereas seems
> to me the sum of the two is more likely the current philosophy. Just
> doesn't seem consistent with the way you assign damage to only one player
> (and of course, someone else was trying to split his damage from an Ophidian
> eye'd creature to both players...)

What there an official answer ever posted to this? (I've been not
reading this newsgroup for a while, and I'm finally catching up. But
even Google Groups doesn't seem to show any answer other than Jeff
Heikkinen's.)

At the prerelease, I ruled that it was the sum of the two
players. The relevant text on Gaea's Liege is "As long as Gaea's Liege
is attacking, its power and toughness are each equal to the number of
Forests defending player controls." I figured that this was similar to
landwalk's text of "A creature with landwalk is unblockable as long as
the defending player controls at least one land with the specified
subtype and/or supertype" being interpreted as "...as long as *a*
defending players controls...", so I treating the Liege as "...number
of Forests *a* defending player controls," meaning that for each Forest,
if it's controlled by a defending player, it counts.

Selecting an opponent seems really strange to me, as it's a static
ability applying all the time. When would you select the opponent?

The only other answer would be for the Liege to have more than one
power/toughness (like the pre-errata Duplicant with more than one
imprinted card). But I didn't want to go there, so I ruled that it was
the sum.

But an official answer to this would be kind of nice.

--
Peter C.
 >> Stay informed about: Gaea's Liege 

"Simon Cooper" <swcooper DeleteThis @conecast.net> writes:
> When Gaea's Liege attacks in a two headed giant game, what's its
> power/toughness?
>
> I suspect I incorrectly ruled for just one player's forests, whereas seems
> to me the sum of the two is more likely the current philosophy. Just
> doesn't seem consistent with the way you assign damage to only one player
> (and of course, someone else was trying to split his damage from an Ophidian
> eye'd creature to both players...)

What there an official answer ever posted to this? (I've been not
reading this newsgroup for a while, and I'm finally catching up. But
even Google Groups doesn't seem to show any answer other than Jeff
Heikkinen's.)

At the prerelease, I ruled that it was the sum of the two
players. The relevant text on Gaea's Liege is "As long as Gaea's Liege
is attacking, its power and toughness are each equal to the number of
Forests defending player controls." I figured that this was similar to
landwalk's text of "A creature with landwalk is unblockable as long as
the defending player controls at least one land with the specified
subtype and/or supertype" being interpreted as "...as long as *a*
defending players controls...", so I treating the Liege as "...number
of Forests *a* defending player controls," meaning that for each Forest,
if it's controlled by a defending player, it counts.

Selecting an opponent seems really strange to me, as it's a static
ability applying all the time. When would you select the opponent?

The only other answer would be for the Liege to have more than one
power/toughness (like the pre-errata Duplicant with more than one
imprinted card). But I didn't want to go there, so I ruled that it was
the sum.

But an official answer to this would be kind of nice.

--
Peter C.
 >> Stay informed about: Gaea's Liege 

"Simon Cooper" <swcooper RemoveThis @conecast.net> writes:
> When Gaea's Liege attacks in a two headed giant game, what's its
> power/toughness?
>
> I suspect I incorrectly ruled for just one player's forests, whereas seems
> to me the sum of the two is more likely the current philosophy. Just
> doesn't seem consistent with the way you assign damage to only one player
> (and of course, someone else was trying to split his damage from an Ophidian
> eye'd creature to both players...)

What there an official answer ever posted to this? (I've been not
reading this newsgroup for a while, and I'm finally catching up. But
even Google Groups doesn't seem to show any answer other than Jeff
Heikkinen's.)

At the prerelease, I ruled that it was the sum of the two
players. The relevant text on Gaea's Liege is "As long as Gaea's Liege
is attacking, its power and toughness are each equal to the number of
Forests defending player controls." I figured that this was similar to
landwalk's text of "A creature with landwalk is unblockable as long as
the defending player controls at least one land with the specified
subtype and/or supertype" being interpreted as "...as long as *a*
defending players controls...", so I treating the Liege as "...number
of Forests *a* defending player controls," meaning that for each Forest,
if it's controlled by a defending player, it counts.

Selecting an opponent seems really strange to me, as it's a static
ability applying all the time. When would you select the opponent?

The only other answer would be for the Liege to have more than one
power/toughness (like the pre-errata Duplicant with more than one
imprinted card). But I didn't want to go there, so I ruled that it was
the sum.

But an official answer to this would be kind of nice.

--
Peter C.
 >> Stay informed about: Gaea's Liege 

"Simon Cooper" <swcooper DeleteThis @conecast.net> writes:
> When Gaea's Liege attacks in a two headed giant game, what's its
> power/toughness?
>
> I suspect I incorrectly ruled for just one player's forests, whereas seems
> to me the sum of the two is more likely the current philosophy. Just
> doesn't seem consistent with the way you assign damage to only one player
> (and of course, someone else was trying to split his damage from an Ophidian
> eye'd creature to both players...)

What there an official answer ever posted to this? (I've been not
reading this newsgroup for a while, and I'm finally catching up. But
even Google Groups doesn't seem to show any answer other than Jeff
Heikkinen's.)

At the prerelease, I ruled that it was the sum of the two
players. The relevant text on Gaea's Liege is "As long as Gaea's Liege
is attacking, its power and toughness are each equal to the number of
Forests defending player controls." I figured that this was similar to
landwalk's text of "A creature with landwalk is unblockable as long as
the defending player controls at least one land with the specified
subtype and/or supertype" being interpreted as "...as long as *a*
defending players controls...", so I treating the Liege as "...number
of Forests *a* defending player controls," meaning that for each Forest,
if it's controlled by a defending player, it counts.

Selecting an opponent seems really strange to me, as it's a static
ability applying all the time. When would you select the opponent?

The only other answer would be for the Liege to have more than one
power/toughness (like the pre-errata Duplicant with more than one
imprinted card). But I didn't want to go there, so I ruled that it was
the sum.

But an official answer to this would be kind of nice.

--
Peter C.
 >> Stay informed about: Gaea's Liege