Dodge vs. Unholy Penance

Wookie813 wrote:
> Looking for confirmation that a dodge will avoid the unnecessarily
> mean effect of UP superior.
> -------------------------------------------
> Unholy Penance
> Cardtype: Combat
> Cost: 1 blood
> Discipline: Presence
> [pre] Strike: combat ends.
> [PRE] As above, and put this card on the opposing minion (ranged). The
> striking vampire gets +1 bleed against this minion's controller. This
> minion may burn this card as a +1 stealth action. A minion can have
> only one Unholy Penance.

Yes, dodge protects the dodging minion.
 >> Stay informed about: Dodge vs. Unholy Penance 

"Dodge. A dodge strike deals no damage, but *** it protects the
dodging
minion and his possessions from the effects of the opposing
strike***.
Retainers are not protected, however. A dodge is effective at any
range. A dodge protects even from the effects of a strike done with
first strike. (A dodge is a strike, even though it is solely
defensive. It represents the activity of the minion during that pair
of strikes.)"

I was thinking that under this definition, combat shouldn't end with a
dodged Anesthetic Touch, is that right?

I mean, I thought (I think I read it somewhere) that even if you
dodged the AT combat would end, but it seems that ending combat it's
an effect and since you're dodging then you're protected and combat
shouldn't end, but I'm not sure anymore.

Anesthetic Touch, Combat, Obeah/Auspex, C1 , [Bloodlines:C1]
Only usable at close range. [aus] Strike: dodge. [obe] Strike: make a
hand strike. Combat ends immediately after the resolution of this
strike. [OBE] As [obe] above, with First Strike.
 >> Stay informed about: Dodge vs. Unholy Penance 

On Oct 23, 3:26 am, Kozkak <tecpat....DeleteThis@hotmail.com> wrote:
> "Dodge. A dodge strike deals no damage, but *** it protects the
> dodging
> minion and his possessions from the effects of the opposing
> strike***.
> Retainers are not protected, however. A dodge is effective at any
> range. A dodge protects even from the effects of a strike done with
> first strike. (A dodge is a strike, even though it is solely
> defensive. It represents the activity of the minion during that pair
> of strikes.)"
>
> I was thinking that under this definition, combat shouldn't end with a
> dodged Anesthetic Touch, is that right?
>
> I mean, I thought (I think I read it somewhere) that even if you
> dodged the AT combat would end, but it seems that ending combat it's
> an effect and since you're dodging then you're protected and combat
> shouldn't end, but I'm not sure anymore.
>
> Anesthetic Touch, Combat, Obeah/Auspex, C1 , [Bloodlines:C1]
> Only usable at close range. [aus] Strike: dodge. [obe] Strike: make a
> hand strike. Combat ends immediately after the resolution of this
> strike. [OBE] As [obe] above, with First Strike.

I think the legalese on this is that the S:CE effect is not directed
at the opposing minion. It is a global effect, and cannot be dodged -
just like the untap clause on Majesty is not lost if the opponent
dodges. Only effects that apply to the opposing minion are avoided by
Strike: Dodge.
 >> Stay informed about: Dodge vs. Unholy Penance 

>>>LSJ & XZealot confirmed

Thanks guys. I just want to be able to say "I checked on the
Newsgroup" if I have to. I appreciate your bothering with me!
 >> Stay informed about: Dodge vs. Unholy Penance 

In message <1193125211.333242.274250.DeleteThis@i38g2000prf.googlegroups.com>,
Wookie813 <veknpontiac.DeleteThis@yahoo.com> writes:
<using Dodge to avoid the combat ends effect of Anesthetic Touch>
>I think the legalese on this is that the S:CE effect is not directed
>at the opposing minion. It is a global effect, and cannot be dodged -
>just like the untap clause on Majesty is not lost if the opponent
>dodges. Only effects that apply to the opposing minion are avoided by
>Strike: Dodge.

Correct.

--
James Coupe
PGP Key: 0x5D623D5D YOU ARE IN ERROR.
EBD690ECD7A1FB457CA2 NO-ONE IS SCREAMING.
13D7E668C3695D623D5D THANK YOU FOR YOUR COOPERATION.
 >> Stay informed about: Dodge vs. Unholy Penance